Sonshi - The original Sun Tzu's Art of War resource
  • Home
  • Sun Tzu
    • Start the path to victory
    • Who was Sun Tzu?
    • What is Sonshi?
    • Sun Tzu's Art of War Translation
    • Best Art of War Books
    • Official Sonshi Art of War book
    • Interviews with Art of War authors and scholars
    • Sun Tzu lives on slideshow
    • Sun Tzu's Way slideshow
    • Articles related to Art of War and strategy
  • Blog
  • Store
  • About
  • Contact
Online since 1999

Crush your enemies, said Sun Tzu never

2/7/2018

6 Comments

 
Picture
Credit: Universal Pictures
Today I encountered a passage from a common but inferior Art of War translation that said, "Hold out baits to entice the enemy. Feign disorder, and crush him."

The passage can be found in Chapter One, Calculations with the Chinese text 利而誘之,亂而取之. I translated it as, "If they seek advantage, bait them; if they are in chaos, capture them."

I have bolded the specific sentence in question above. One can also translate it as "take" them or even "invade" them, but "crush" them is careless and misleading. It seems like a small difference but it is not. It is a chasm. It is like hearing the commander say, "Seize this city" and interpreting it as "Destroy this city."

The accuracy of a sentence's translation is one important consideration, but let's also look at that sentence's alignment with Sun Tzu's key principles. If you consider the overall context of The Art of War, the book's advice is clear. Below are five examples of passages that run counter to "crush him":
(1) "Generally in warfare, keeping a nation intact is best, destroying a nation second best; keeping an army intact is best, destroying an army second best; keeping a battalion intact is best, destroying a battalion second best; keeping a company intact is best, destroying a company second best; keeping a squad intact is best, destroying a squad second best." Sun Tzu
Sun Tzu prefers preservation of gains over crushing anybody or anything and losing those gains. Thus, if the enemy is in chaos and you have the initiative, why would you want to crush him when you can leave him whole? 
(2) "If ten times the enemy's strength, surround them ... Do not thwart an enemy retreating home. If you surround the enemy, leave an outlet; do not press an enemy that is cornered. These are the principles of warfare." Sun Tzu
When the enemy is in chaos, it is in a disadvantaged and weak position. In contrast, we are in an advantaged and strong position. As Sun Tzu advised above, the wise move would not be to "crush him," but to surround him. The enemy poses no threat and we are vastly superior. So it makes sense we would leave an outlet so they can retreat home. This is analogous to a caring big brother holding off his sibling versus a mean bully pursuing his victim. Sun Tzu tops off this passage by saying it is a principle of war.
(3) "One who is skilled in warfare principles subdues the enemy without doing battle, takes the enemy's walled city without attacking, and overthrows the enemy quickly, without protracted warfare. His aim must be to take All-Under-Heaven intact. Therefore, weapons will not be blunted, and gains will be intact. These are the principles of planning attacks." Sun Tzu
The benefit of receiving Sun Tzu's instruction is to be a wise leader in situations of emotional conflict. We want to become skilled, controlled, and competent. As such, our goal as mentioned above is to "take All-Under-Heaven intact." Similar to our previous example, Sun Tzu ended the verse by stating it is a principle of planning attacks. According to Sun Tzu, one would never want to plan to crush the enemy. That would be when there is a breakdown in the execution of our aim, something we would not want to happen, much less plan for.
(4) "Replace the enemy's flags and standards with our own. Mix the captured chariots with our own and treat the captured soldiers well. This is called defeating the enemy and increasing our strength." Sun Tzu
The quote above is hardly from a person who would promote crushing an enemy. It would seem he wants to not only capture the enemy unharmed but also try to incorporate them into his own forces. Again, the difference in the two ideas is vast.

​And last, this is one of my most favorite quotes in The Art of War:
(5) "Those angry will be happy again, and those wrathful will be cheerful again, but a destroyed nation cannot exist again, the dead cannot be brought back to life. Therefore, the enlightened ruler is prudent, the good general is cautious. This is the Way of securing the nation, and preserving the army." Sun Tzu
Sun Tzu was a man of great compassion, because he was a man of great strength and wisdom. He understood the objective isn't to "crush" or destroy the opponent but to quickly achieve equilibrium. His desire seems focused on treading lightly, doing as little harm as possible, and return things back to normal again. In other words, war isn't normal. Peace is normal.

Critics will say this sort of peace is only temporary. But everything is temporary. In a changing world, nothing is ever permanent. Sun Tzu had the ability to handle war and conflict with aplomb. Therefore, it is better for him to establish peace right now when violence has broken out than to achieve an idealized permanent peace later on. Along those same lines, it is better to start building bridges and wait to be able to complete it in the future -- Sun Tzu's concept of timing -- than to induce, continue, or exacerbate hatred now and crush any hope of success in the future.
6 Comments
Rosa Maria
2/7/2018 08:12:59 am

Simply wow! I am a mediator and this quotes are very useful to use in my Mediation trainer
Please help me find relations between The Art of War and conflict Resolution through Mediation

Thank you

Reply
Thomas Huynh link
2/7/2018 08:21:39 am

You're welcome. I suppose a general is a mediator of two political states. His job is to de-escalate the actions the aggressor.

Reply
Kevin Chan link
2/7/2018 10:06:59 am

Rosa, you may consider writing a book on the application of Sun Tzu's philosophy in conflict resolution and mediation so that more people may learn about it.

Reply
Thomas Huynh link
2/7/2018 12:07:08 pm

100% agree!

Kevin Chan link
2/7/2018 10:03:01 am

Here we go again, once again, can't people see how Sun Tzu's philosophy in warfare is so wise and applicable in today's healthcare mentality on "crushing" the diseases with therapies that often times harm the host as much as the "enemies" without attempting to achieve "All-Under-Heaven intact?" What would the healthcare system be like if our society can adopt Sun Tzu's philosophy?

Reply
Thonas Huynh link
2/7/2018 12:55:16 pm

Doesn't the Hippocratic Oath boil down to first do no harm? (noxamvero et maleficium propulsabo)

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Thomas Cuong Huynh, founder of Sonshi

    Picture

    Archives

    March 2023
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2020
    April 2020
    September 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017


    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

SONSHI - THE ORIGINAL SUN TZU'S ART OF WAR RESOURCE
​"Winning battles such that the whole world cries, 'Excellent!' is not the highest excellence." Sun Tzu
Privacy Policy
© 1999-2022 Sonshi.com. All rights reserved. The name SONSHI® and "four-leaf clover" logo are registered, incontestable trademarks of the Sonshi Group 和平的力量.